Gretchen Brinza
Email me!
  • Home
  • About Me
  • School
    • Louisville Middle School >
      • 2021-2022 >
        • 6th Grade: Contact Forces/Collisions!
        • 8th: Patterns in Space and Sky
        • 6th: Bath Bombs
        • 8th: Climate--The Warming Arctic
        • 8th: Hail, Rain & Snow
        • 6th: Cups
        • 8th: Tsunami-Natural Hazards
        • 6th: One-Way Mirror
        • 8th: Mt. Everest & Other Mtns
    • Sauganash >
      • 2020-2021 >
        • 5th Grade >
          • Data in Science
          • Human Impact (+/-)
          • The Dead Raccoon
          • Clean/Dirty Water
          • Opening Routines
        • 6th Grade >
          • Healing
          • A Changing Landscape
          • Keeping Things Hot or Cold!?!?!
          • One-Way Mirror
          • Dogs (Well and Unwell)!
          • Opening Routines
      • 2019-2020 >
        • 5th Grade >
          • The Sky
          • Dead Raccoon
          • All Things Water!
        • 6th Grade >
          • Sick Dog
          • Mt. Everest
          • Cups
    • Alcott >
      • 2018-2019 >
        • 5th Grade >
          • Patterns in the Sky
          • Roadkill--Dead Stuff
          • Down the Drain...
        • 6th Grade >
          • Chickens!
          • Sounds From a Distance
          • Sick Dogs
          • Spooky ________!
      • 2017-2018 >
        • 5th Grade >
          • The Mystery Sun
          • Roadkill
          • Clean/Dirty Water
        • 6th Grade >
          • Changing Populations
          • Smelling Lots of Stuff
          • Seeing and Light
      • 2016-2017 >
        • 6th Grade >
          • Can I Believe My Eyes?
          • How Can I Smell Things From a Distance?
          • Where Have All the Creatures Gone?
        • 5th Grade >
          • Unknown Chemicals' Identities?
          • Data
          • Water Transformations
          • The Raccoon Mystery
        • Technology Integration
      • 2015-2016 >
        • 5th Grade >
          • Opening Procedures
          • Chemical Tests
          • Earth's Systems Science
          • Data (Moon, Daylight, Temp., Constellations)
          • Ships in a Field
          • Patterns
        • 6th Grade >
          • Opening Procedures
          • World of Wonder Projects
          • Can I Believe My Eyes?
          • How Can I Smell From a Distance?
          • Where Have All the Creatures Gone?
    • STEM Magnet Academy >
      • A Glimpse Into My Classroom
      • Fifth Grade >
        • 5th Grade: 2013-2014 >
          • Environmental Engineering (Part II)
          • Aerospace Engineering
      • Fourth Grade >
        • 4th Grade: 2014-2015 >
          • Environmental Engineering
          • Waves and their Applications for Information Transfer
        • 4th Grade: 2013-2014 >
          • Environmental Engineering
          • Transportation Engineering
          • Biomedical Engineering
        • 4th Grade: 2012-2013 >
          • Environmental Engineering
          • Transportation Engineering
          • Biomedical Engineering
      • Third Grade >
        • 3rd Grade: 2014-2015 >
          • Forces and Interactions
        • 3rd Grade: 2013-2014 >
          • Electrical Engineering
          • Acoustical Engineering
          • Optical Engineering
        • 3rd Grade: 2012-2013 >
          • Acoustical Engineering
          • Electrical Engineering
          • Optical Engineering
      • Second Grade >
        • 2nd Grade: 2014-2015 >
          • Geotechnical Engineering
          • Matter and Its Interactions!
        • 2nd Grade: 2012-2013 >
          • Geotechnical Engineering
          • Ocean Engineering
          • Packaging Engineering
        • 2nd Grade: 2013-2014 >
          • Geotechnical Engineering
          • Civil Engineering
          • Ocean Engineering
      • First Grade >
        • 1st Grade: 2014-2015 >
          • Optical Engineering
          • Sound
          • Plants--Structures and Processes
        • 1st Grade: 2013-2014 >
          • Materials Engineering
          • Mechanical Engineering
          • Agricultural Engineering
        • 1st Grade: 2012-2013 >
          • Mechanical Engineering
          • Materials Engineering
          • Agricultural Engineering
      • Kindergarten >
        • Engineers do what?
        • Forces and Interactions!
        • Earth and Human Activity
        • K: 2013-2014 >
          • Introduction to Engineering
          • Force and Motion
          • Fabric
        • K: 2012-2013 >
          • Introduction to Engineering
          • All About Fabric
          • Built By Nature
        • Check it out! >
          • Exciting News
          • National Engineers Week
          • Donations
          • Chicago Events
  • PAEMST
  • Other
    • STEM FAIR 2019
    • STEM Fair 2018
    • Tech-Class
    • Engineering Week
    • G.D.W.O.F.
    • MSU Urban STEM >
      • Summer Work >
        • Ultimate STEM
        • ImagineIT >
          • Phase 1
          • Phase 2
          • Phase 3
        • Deep Play
        • Quickfires
        • Reflections >
          • Summer
        • Cosmos
      • Fall Work >
        • Deep Play Group
        • ImagineIT >
          • Phase 4
          • Phase 5
          • Phase 6
      • Spring Work >
        • Leadership
        • ImagineIT

Other Substances and Heating/Cooling: Do They Do What Water Does?

10/26/2018

 
So we figured out a lot about water and what happens to it as it is heated and cooled.  Since we know fog has something to do with water, this makes sense.  But it also makes sense to investigate what other other substances do with hotter and colder temperatures since other things like CCNs and air play a role in making fog.  So overnight, students brainstormed some Investigation Ideas to test this in Google Forms. Here are some of their results, and after a discussion...
Picture
We began the investigations, noticing what happened, and developing some models to see if air and other substances behave like water when it is heated and cooled.

Heating Up A Bottle with Bubble Solution on Top

Heating Up a Bottle with a Balloon on Top

Heating and Cooling Vinegar (Using pH Paper as an Indicator)

We figured out a lot from all these investigations, and it seems that water, vinegar and air molecules all act the same way:

1.  Molecules move faster and take up more space when they're heated.
2.  Molecules move slower and take up more space when they're cooled.

From all our investigations, though, we would LOVE to see what is really going on with the molecules, since our ability to show movement with them is kind of limited being static on paper.  Is there a way we can better see what's going on at the molecular level...IN REAL TIME?

Heating and Cooling Water: Evidence!

10/25/2018

 
So we are leaning towards a temperature change being a missing factor to make fog. We've gotten lots of humidity in the air, and we've also added tons of CCNs. Still NO FOG!  So we're figuring out what's really going on with the molecules as they change temperatures.  W're doing this because we noticed in our weather data that every city that has fog has experienced some sort of temperature drop when the fog appears, and then the temperature increases when the fog disappears.  
We're making a public record of what we figure out, and so far, we've come to the following agreement:

1.  Hot water molecules move faster and take up more space than cold water molecules.
2.  Therefore, cold water molecules move slower and take up less space than hot water molecules.

We saw this happen in the food coloring demonstration, where the food coloring spread out SUPER quickly in the hot water but super slowly in the cold water.  And in the test tube demonstration, we saw the water expand up the tube as it was placed in a hot water bath and take up less space when it was cooled down.

Now the question is, does every substance do this?  Like air?  

We're Stuck. Looking into Temperature

10/24/2018

 
So despite adding CCNs into the air with high humidity, we didn't make fog. We went back to the drawing board to see what else can help us figure out fog, especially since we have some really insightful questions on the DQB...like

"How do CCNs get into the air?"
AND
"How does water actually condense on a CCN?"

We don't really know where to go, but one factor that has been looming in the background is related to temperature.
Picture
We know that for water to "clump" together it has to get cooler like it did as it got farther away from the humidifier.  We also wanted to see if we saw any temperature changes with each of the cities we investigated early on that experienced fog.  And for every city, a trend began to appear that before the fog appeared, the temperature began to drop.  In some cities, there was a BIG drop in temperature, like by more than 10 degrees Fahrenheit.  In other cities there was a much SMALLER drop, but it was still a drop  by like 2 degrees Farenheit.  We also saw that when the fog disappeared, we saw an increase in temperature (again, but varying amounts, but still an increase).

We've got some questions about temperature's role with fog (especially since we don't think there's an "ideal" temperature for fog since it appears in cities with VERY different average temperatures (think Ashland, WI and Orlando, FL).  So we decided our next steps should be to investigate what happens to substances when they are heated and cooled, and we'd start with water since that's obviously needed for fog.

​M

Attempting Fog Again (with our knowledge of CCNs)

10/24/2018

 
We agreed that after putting some CCNs into the humid air produced by our humidifiers wasn't quite what we expected. So after brainstorming what could possibly have gone wrong, we updated our "We Didn't Make Fog Because..." lists to include:

1. Maybe we didn't put enough CCNs into the air?
2. Maybe we didn't  wait long enough?
3.  Maybe we didn't get it cold enough for the water molecules to condense on the CCNs?
4.  Maybe we weren't using the right CCNs?
We're kind of stumped.  We've got humid air, and we've got CCNs.  We're trying to make the water molecules condense onto the CCNs that are there (and we know are there because we added more to the air). But what are we missing???  Back to the drawing board today to think about what other factors may be playing a role in helping produce fog.  We can do this!

Publicly Posting...Adding New Questions...and Adding CCNs!

10/18/2018

 
Students pushed to revisit the DQB now that we figured out a lot about fog and the role of CCNs!  So we did just that...publicly posting what we have figured out to a LOT of the questions we asked!  Anything you see on GREEN means it's a question students felt they had figured out and answered. All new questions are on pink Post-Its!  Questions that we still haven't answered are on light-yellow Post-Its. 
This is the other class' DQB updated.  Anything you see on yellow paper are questions students felt they answered.  Any all new questions are on orange Post-It notes.  
We then decided to honor everyone's investigation ideas and add CCNs to the humidity we could make in our classroom.  And here's some evidence of the fog we made...or wait!  Is it fog?!?!?!  We'll be looking into what may be the reasons behind what happened and honor other investigation ideas.  What about that fog juice thing?!??!

CCNs...Huh?

10/17/2018

 
So from all our articles on fog appearances, we figured out that there was something else in the air along with high humidity when fog happens.  With some research, we discovered these really small, yet really important molecules, called cloud condensation nuclei, or CCNs for short.  These particles are things like dust, smoke, ash, or dirt and they allow water vapor to condense on them.  As water vapor molecules are attracted to one another and condense on a CCN, they make a fog droplet! As more and more water molecules condense, we think the fog must get thicker and thicker--or maybe the size of the CCN plays a role, we're not sure.  
We spent a lot of time thinking and discussing this process...only to revise our fog models yet again.  It seems like we have discovered the missing piece to our fog!  And it also means that when we thought we were making fog on Friday, we were really just making steam.  
From our modeling and feedback to one another through a gallery walk, we established consensus on how a fog droplet is formed:
​
Picture
It seems like we were missing some CCNs in our classroom!  So we brainstormed some investigation ideas to get CCNs into our classroom (safely), and came up with these ideas:
We think that tomorrow we'll have some FOG!  Oh yeah!

A Resounding NO FOG!

10/15/2018

 
So we had a complete agreement that we didn't make fog on Friday.  While we thought we made something (most likely steam), we definitely had consensus that it wasn't thick enough or long-lasting enough to be considered fog.

So...students mentioned in their reflections over the weekend that we should investigate a bunch of things next, and the vast majority said the following:

1.  Look into that fog machine!  What does it do differently than what we are doing to make our fog?

2.  Research natural fog more in depth--what is it that makes natural fog thicker and last longer than the fog we made?  Is there something more to it than high humidity?

3.  Change the temperature more--it seems like we couldn't make the water hot or cold enough when we wanted to and this might make the water clump together more.

So Mrs. Brinza decided to investigate student ideas and went to a Halloween Store to investigate the fog machine.  The store manager was kind enough to let her see the "info sheet" in a new fog machine box (Mrs. Brinza scored one on clearance and it didn't have an "info" sheet like a brand new one).  She took a picture and distributed the findings to students in class on Monday.  ​
Picture
The "Fog Juice" info sheet suggested that the fog machine doesn't just use water!  This totally made sense since we figured out that when we used just water in our fog machines, we didn't end up with fog!

It seems like fog juice is a mixture, made up of water and glycerine. Is glycerine what's in natural fog?  Would research help us?

Mrs. Brinza found some neat articles on natural fog to help us with this wondering...
Picture
From each of these articles where fog was present naturally, we uncovered some things.  First off, there always seemed to be humid air (which we already have figured out).  There was something to do with warm/cold air (which we're not really sure about).  And there was something about something else being in the air, like smoke, dust, tree particles, dust, or pollution.  Maybe these are the "missing factors" of what causes fog to happen!?!?!  What can we do next to see if this helps us make thick, long-lasting spooky fog?

Building Our Fog Machines!!!

10/12/2018

 
Whoah!  What a crazy day!  We had a lot going on (blew two circuit breakers and burnt a little bit of plastic) but we all did an INCREDIBLE JOB designing our fog machines.  We had a lot of ideas being tested, but sadly....

NO THICK, LONG-LASTING, LOW-TO-THE-GROUND FOG.

Back to the drawing board.  What are we missing? What science ideas do we need to figure out still that's not causing our fog to look and act like the natural fog we see all the time?  Thank goodness we have the weekend to reflect!

Revised Models of Fog!

10/12/2018

 
So we decided to revisit our models of fog to prepare us well to design our fog machines!  It's important that groups come to a consensus for how they think fog is made so when they begin engineering, they'll know what to do!  Here are a few groups' models of the difference between when fog is present and when it's not present.
There were a couple ideas that surfaced:

1.  Fog happens when there's a lot of humidity in the air, so we would have to get a lot of water into the air with either the humidifiers or by boiling it.

2.  The water must clump together (we know water molecules are attracted to each other) and the the more they clump together, the more they are visible.  Since we see fog, we must have to push these pieces together either by forces them together with less space, or cooling them down.

And our conversations led us into our designs!  ​We planned out our initial fog machine designs individually, and then came together as a table.  Be on the lookout for our fog machine results!  Fingers crossed we make thick, low-lying, long-lasting SPOOKY FOG!

Revising Our Fog Models

10/9/2018

 
We are certainly anticipating the building of our fog machines!  But before we do that, we figured it would be good to do TWO things: 

1. Celebrate all that we've accomplished in figuring out so far by visiting the DQB to see if we answered any questions, which we did!  And we're publicly posting what we figured out!
Picture
2. Recreate our models of fog knowing that since mid-September, we've figured out a lot about water, air, and humidity, which all play a role in the creation of fog.  Here are our "Gotta Have It" checklists for our models of fog (from the two classes of sixth graders):
<<Previous

    Driving Question

    How can we produce a bunch of fog for a spooky scene?

    Archives

    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly