Gretchen Brinza
Email me!
  • Home
  • About Me
  • School
    • Louisville Middle School >
      • 2021-2022 >
        • 6th Grade: Contact Forces/Collisions!
        • 8th: Patterns in Space and Sky
        • 6th: Bath Bombs
        • 8th: Climate--The Warming Arctic
        • 8th: Hail, Rain & Snow
        • 6th: Cups
        • 8th: Tsunami-Natural Hazards
        • 6th: One-Way Mirror
        • 8th: Mt. Everest & Other Mtns
    • Sauganash >
      • 2020-2021 >
        • 5th Grade >
          • Data in Science
          • Human Impact (+/-)
          • The Dead Raccoon
          • Clean/Dirty Water
          • Opening Routines
        • 6th Grade >
          • Healing
          • A Changing Landscape
          • Keeping Things Hot or Cold!?!?!
          • One-Way Mirror
          • Dogs (Well and Unwell)!
          • Opening Routines
      • 2019-2020 >
        • 5th Grade >
          • The Sky
          • Dead Raccoon
          • All Things Water!
        • 6th Grade >
          • Sick Dog
          • Mt. Everest
          • Cups
    • Alcott >
      • 2018-2019 >
        • 5th Grade >
          • Patterns in the Sky
          • Roadkill--Dead Stuff
          • Down the Drain...
        • 6th Grade >
          • Chickens!
          • Sounds From a Distance
          • Sick Dogs
          • Spooky ________!
      • 2017-2018 >
        • 5th Grade >
          • The Mystery Sun
          • Roadkill
          • Clean/Dirty Water
        • 6th Grade >
          • Changing Populations
          • Smelling Lots of Stuff
          • Seeing and Light
      • 2016-2017 >
        • 6th Grade >
          • Can I Believe My Eyes?
          • How Can I Smell Things From a Distance?
          • Where Have All the Creatures Gone?
        • 5th Grade >
          • Unknown Chemicals' Identities?
          • Data
          • Water Transformations
          • The Raccoon Mystery
        • Technology Integration
      • 2015-2016 >
        • 5th Grade >
          • Opening Procedures
          • Chemical Tests
          • Earth's Systems Science
          • Data (Moon, Daylight, Temp., Constellations)
          • Ships in a Field
          • Patterns
        • 6th Grade >
          • Opening Procedures
          • World of Wonder Projects
          • Can I Believe My Eyes?
          • How Can I Smell From a Distance?
          • Where Have All the Creatures Gone?
    • STEM Magnet Academy >
      • A Glimpse Into My Classroom
      • Fifth Grade >
        • 5th Grade: 2013-2014 >
          • Environmental Engineering (Part II)
          • Aerospace Engineering
      • Fourth Grade >
        • 4th Grade: 2014-2015 >
          • Environmental Engineering
          • Waves and their Applications for Information Transfer
        • 4th Grade: 2013-2014 >
          • Environmental Engineering
          • Transportation Engineering
          • Biomedical Engineering
        • 4th Grade: 2012-2013 >
          • Environmental Engineering
          • Transportation Engineering
          • Biomedical Engineering
      • Third Grade >
        • 3rd Grade: 2014-2015 >
          • Forces and Interactions
        • 3rd Grade: 2013-2014 >
          • Electrical Engineering
          • Acoustical Engineering
          • Optical Engineering
        • 3rd Grade: 2012-2013 >
          • Acoustical Engineering
          • Electrical Engineering
          • Optical Engineering
      • Second Grade >
        • 2nd Grade: 2014-2015 >
          • Geotechnical Engineering
          • Matter and Its Interactions!
        • 2nd Grade: 2012-2013 >
          • Geotechnical Engineering
          • Ocean Engineering
          • Packaging Engineering
        • 2nd Grade: 2013-2014 >
          • Geotechnical Engineering
          • Civil Engineering
          • Ocean Engineering
      • First Grade >
        • 1st Grade: 2014-2015 >
          • Optical Engineering
          • Sound
          • Plants--Structures and Processes
        • 1st Grade: 2013-2014 >
          • Materials Engineering
          • Mechanical Engineering
          • Agricultural Engineering
        • 1st Grade: 2012-2013 >
          • Mechanical Engineering
          • Materials Engineering
          • Agricultural Engineering
      • Kindergarten >
        • Engineers do what?
        • Forces and Interactions!
        • Earth and Human Activity
        • K: 2013-2014 >
          • Introduction to Engineering
          • Force and Motion
          • Fabric
        • K: 2012-2013 >
          • Introduction to Engineering
          • All About Fabric
          • Built By Nature
        • Check it out! >
          • Exciting News
          • National Engineers Week
          • Donations
          • Chicago Events
  • PAEMST
  • Other
    • STEM FAIR 2019
    • STEM Fair 2018
    • Tech-Class
    • Engineering Week
    • G.D.W.O.F.
    • MSU Urban STEM >
      • Summer Work >
        • Ultimate STEM
        • ImagineIT >
          • Phase 1
          • Phase 2
          • Phase 3
        • Deep Play
        • Quickfires
        • Reflections >
          • Summer
        • Cosmos
      • Fall Work >
        • Deep Play Group
        • ImagineIT >
          • Phase 4
          • Phase 5
          • Phase 6
      • Spring Work >
        • Leadership
        • ImagineIT

Looking at Elevation Data

10/26/2017

 
Students recognized that water flowing makes a lot of sense when elevation (the word we learned to replace tilt-angle-steepness) can be identified.  We went back to the ArcGIS maps we used earlier, and changed them to show elevation with a color code.  We focused on the Chicago area, and then moved to see the Great Lakes and eventually the majority of the continental US.  Students began making some predictions and saw a pattern emerge.   
While the colored maps were beautiful, they were hard to really know where the water flowed.  Students then wanted to know if there was a better way...

We noticed Denver on the map, and when asked it's nickname, someone said "THE MILE HIGH CITY!"

While Denver isn't of hug importance to us here in Chicago, it made students think that every city has an elevation value.  With some research, students plotted the elevations of cities throughout the US:  
Picture
The vast majority of water around us eventually leads to the Gulf of Mexico, and ultimately the Atlantic ocean.  Now that we know this, this is getting us concerned.  Our treated water leads to the ocean, which contains SALT water! 

And as one student said it, "Why are we working so hard to clean our dirty water only for it to end up in the ocean where there's something else in it that we can't drink?  Why don't we keep the water near us?"

What other new questions will students come up with?  Especially as this relates to us and how we get our clean drinking water! (the other part of our Driving Question!)

Building a New Model

10/25/2017

 
The class agreed that the tilt of the container seemed to get the water to flow the most, but the wall of the container and its small size were of concern to us.  We decided to build a better model of where a river would be, and this could hopefully gather more evidence to support the claim that there needs to be an angle in the river in order to get the water flowing in one direction.

​So we built a landscape!  Mrs. Brinza had an old tablecloth lying around, and we raised up part of the "land" by putting stuff under it to show how land isn't flat.  We used orange cones, cups, and some cotton patting to show this.  Then Mrs. Brinza made it rain!
Picture
We figured out a lot of information from this physical model.  We gathered more evidence to support the idea that water flows downward, and we saw the water move faster in areas that were steeper.  Water that gathered did so in places that were flat, and it didn't move there at all. Students were asked to explain their thinking by developing a model themselves.
From here, we're trying to figure out how this big idea connects to what we're trying to figure out...where our clean drinking water comes from.  We know how water flows...so how does this all relate back to the concerns we had regarding the Chicago River and Lake Michigan?  How can flow help us better understand this?

Water's Flow

10/23/2017

 
We agreed that our next best steps would be to figure out how water flows since our treated water may end up where we get our drinking water. But no one knew if water from the Chicago River flows into Lake Michigan, or if the lake flows into the river.  This will make a BIG difference to us!

From there, a lot of students chimed in that they know that other rivers connect to the Chicago River, and some students even suggested that the Chicago River flows into other rivers.  We even heard talk about water leading to the ocean.

So before we could figure all that stuff out, we agreed to figure out all about flow.  Here's are the summaries between the two fifth grade classes about how we could investigate how water flows.
Picture
So both classes agreed to the following investigations:
1.  Use a toy boat (like a wind-up toy) to see if boats make the water flow.
2.  Use a straw/fan to mimic the wind, and see if that's what causes flowing water.
3.  Build a river, and see how it flows.

​Here are some still shots from what we saw today:
We figured out that the toy boat (all we had access to was a toy scuba diver that moved) and the wind didn't really make the water flow, although it slightly influenced the water's direction. We also figured out that there must have been a time where there were no boats on any type of water way, and the water must still have flowed then.  And the same is true for wind...while it influences the water, sometimes there's no wind and the water in the river still flows.

​ Building a riverbed with sand that Mrs. Brinza had didn't really do much either.  So we were kind of stumped.  How could we get the water in the river to move consistently, in one direction, and ultimately flow like the rivers we've all seen?  
Someone suggested to raise one end of the container, and the moment we did that, the water from one end moved to the other end.  Now there was only a limited amount of water in the container, so someone suggested we added more water, and we did.

So there was four things we noticed:

1.  The water did flow downwards, until it got stopped by the wall of the container.  

2.  We needed to add more water to see if it kept flowing (which it did).

3.  Our container seemed kind of small, so we wanted to see what would happen on a larger scaled-model.

4.  The sand seemed to be really absorbent of the water, and became super saturated, possibly affecting our results.
Picture
So we all agreed that we should build a better model tomorrow to better represent this idea that hills/tilts/angles (or whatever students were calling them) are important in understanding how water flows. 

​We're not quite sure about the following:

1.  What gets water to keep refilling the top (like where Mrs. Brinza poured the bucket of water from the bucket)?

2.  Where does the water go from a river?  Like where does it stop?  Or lead to?

3.  If water moves downwards, how can a river flow even it appears flat?

Our Next Steps (Knowing Where Chicago's Water Goes)

10/20/2017

 
Knowing what we know now, that the wastewater treatment facility in Chicago (at least the major one) dumps its treated water into the Chicago River, we zoomed in on this part of the Chicago River...
Picture
We really looked at this area and came up with some great questions:
We agreed that we really need to know where the water flows, so our next steps involve figuring out that.  IF the Chicago River flows into Lake Michigan, then we've got some problems on our hands...

Using Maps to Determine Where Chicago's Water Goes

10/19/2017

 
We used the ArcGIS map found here to see our location compared to our nearest wastewater treatment plants.  The images below are screenshots Mrs. Brinza took, and the green triangles are wastewater treatment plants.  The blue note is where our school is located.   We have a hunch that our treated water goes into the river that runs through our city, the Chicago River. 
But we also noticed that some of the treatment facilities are located near Lake Michigan, and if we zoom out far enough see that the Chicago River connects to other rivers.  This got us thinking...

1.  How do these rivers and Lake Michigan connect, if they do at all?
2.  Which way do the rivers flow, since there are so many of them?
3.  Why don't the rivers keep overflowing if we dump the treated water there?
4.  And if we get our drinking water from Lake Michigan like many students have heard we do, why should we care that the treated water ends up in the river if they don't have anything to do with one another?

We've got some investigating to do!!!

Looking Deeper at a Wastewater Treatment Facility

10/19/2017

 
So we realized that some of our ingredients we put into our water are dissolved.  And we've pretty much figured out that they're so small our physical means of getting them out do not work.

So we wondered...is this what really happens at a wastewater treatment facility?  Are they unable to get all the dissolved stuff out, too?

So we went back to the drawing board and figured out our next best steps would be to go to the wastewater treatment facility nearest us.  But Mrs. Brinza found out we have to be at least 12 to go on a field trip there (and most students are only 10 or 11).  She's contacted a guest speaker to come in, but that takes some time to arrange.  We did watch some videos earlier, so we'll go back to those since that's like a virtual field trip.

​Here's the two videos we watched:
We figured out a lot of answers to the questions we asked.  Here's a quick summary of what we figured out:

1.  There's three ways they clean the water--physically, biologically, and chemically.
2.  The wastewater treatment plant removes 85-95% of the dissolved stuff.  
3.  The remaining part, along with the cleaner water is known as treated water.  Chemicals are added to further clean it (and kill any harmful bacteria).
4.  The treated water then enters the two cities' (New York and London) closest rivers.

We organized our findings into two graphic organizers, a data table on the left and a concept map on the right (see below)

Agreeing on the Model for Our Dirty Water; Next Steps!

10/17/2017

 
After looking at many models from students, we came to an agreement on what our dirty water that we made looks like with all the dissolved solids in it.  Here's what the two classes created:
After thinking about our models, we're still really concerned that the wastewater treatment facility isn't able to remove all the "stuff" in the water, especially since we think it has to get dumped back into our waterways (although we're not certain of this yet).  

We figured our next steps would be to do some research, and from our research online and watching some videos of wastewater treatment plants in action, here's what we figured out and then organized (based on the two cities we had information for)!
Picture

Modeling Dissolving and the Dirty Water Post-Filtering!

10/15/2017

 
Before we finalize our thinking about this dirty water that we tried REALLY hard to clean, we've determined that the water has stuff in it that's too small to see.  Stuff is there...and it's dissolved.  It's making us think about this water that leaves the wastewater treatment facility.

Students were asked to expand their thinking into modeling salt dissolving.  Here's what some students were thinking...

Modeling Salt Dissolving

Modeling the Dirty Water (with vinegar and the dissolved solids)

And while we've become more knowledgeable about modeling and everything made of "pieces," we're STILL thinking about that water that's been cleaned ​ at the wastewater treatment facility. What exactly is in it that we can't see?  Where does it go if there is still stuff in it they can't get out!?!?!?!

Models for Water and the Other Stuff...

10/11/2017

 
After we worked through a model together of salt and water, students were to create their own  models for the remaining three ingredients...

We'll be figuring out the strengths and weaknesses to each of their models and come to an agreement about what we figured out!
After discussing all the models for each ingredient before and after it entered the water, here's what we figured out:

1.  Everything is made of pieces--solids and liquids.   The water and vinegar MUST be made of pieces because they fit through a coffee filter, too.
2.  Water pieces and vinegar pieces must be smaller than the pieces of everything else.
3.  When something dissolves, it breaks down into smaller pieces and it spreads out evenly in the liquid it dissolves in.  If it didn't spread out evenly, we'd still see all those tiny little pieces clumped together.  

Evaluating Our Models

10/6/2017

 
So we came to an agreement from sharing our models that we could represent the dissolved salt, sugar and citric acid as pieces.  We know that each ingredient got smaller and smaller when it entered the water, and that we could eventually NOT see it anymore, and all our tests yesterday gave us evidence that they were still there.  

But one thing we were stumped on is the vinegar.  We don't really know how to show that it was there because we couldn't see any pieces under the microscope, so we left it as one big blob like the water.

So Mrs. Brinza helped students change their 2D thinking into 3D thinking.  She brought out the base-10 blocks and built something similar to this picture: 
Picture
Building water as one big blob makes sense for how we actually see a cup of water, but it doesn't make sense for how water actually behaves and for how an ingredient like salt, reacts with it.  In our model on the left, the salt (represented by orange pieces), sits on top.  This is NOT what it does when it enters the water.  When it enters the water, it's able to move through the water.  Through a thoughtful discussion, we realized that the water must be in pieces in order to let the salt through.  It also made sense to have water be pieces because that's the only explanation for how it fit through a coffee filter when we were trying to get out the other stuff.  

​We tried to represent everything we've learned about this stuff we can't see and how water behaves in a model below.  Here is our work!
<<Previous

    Mrs. Brinza

    There's nothing like a nice cold glass of water on a warm day.  I kind of take advantage of that clean water quite often...

    Archives

    May 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly